I've tossed almost all of the super-hookers from team Utah. I've owned all 3 Defiants, Critical Theory, Lucid, and both VG Nano's. I also got to toss the Sync at a Matchmaker, but don't own one yet. It should, based on the cover and the core numbers, be the "strongest" out of them all.
If you are looking for a hard arc, I would personally choose the Defiant solid. It hooks a ton, but is not jumpy on the back. The Nano solid is quite similar, with a bit more angularity. I haven't used the Soul enough yet to give honest feedback, but I can see it being my favorite out of all the balls mentioned. The Critical is a ton of ball, but probably the most angular out of them all. It has a great reaction for an oiler.
I may get some grief for mentioning this, but I would also consider the IQ Tour. I know that it is supposed to be "weaker" than everything mentioned, but I have found it to be as much ball as anything else I own. It has the benefit of being super smooth the whole way down the lane, making it easy to read. With some surface, it truly is a monster. It is one of my favorite pieces, but it tends to get overlooked as an oiler due to the core numbers.
Keep in mind that all this is based off my game, with my layouts and choices of surfaces. What works well for me may not for you. I'm just giving you the feedback from my personal experiences. Good luck!
Don