HRPS and Recharge have different covers and different cores; of course they will be different. HRPS will handle some more carrydown than the Recharge, being solid vs pearl.
Is your HRPS drilled also with pin over bridge?
The Recharge has a taller core, which makes it more skid/flip than the rounder core of the HRPS, even though the Recharge has more flare (which might have reduced with the long pin-PAP distance).
Pearls with pin over bridge can be very sensitive to carrydown or anything approaching wet/drys; they can even make blends seem wet/dry. Following a ladies league with potentially lots of pretty plastic balls, there can be LOTS of carrydown. I'd only suggest that you make sure you hit the dry area with the Recharge.
The pearlized Recharge, especially with pin over bridge, may be better saved for drier conditions, when the HRPS either burns up in the midlane or can't make the turn; then, maybe, pull out the Recharge.