Thanks for the suggestions. Yesterday, I tried doing a light sanding of 1500 to see if that would help the ball recover. That did not really work well, so I ended up going to the resurfacing. I took the suggestion of 360/500 and then applied Step 2. Using the Anarchy tonight in heavy oil along with my Nano, it did have a lot more teeth in the ball and was performing better than it had been. I don't think it was the exact best condition to throw it, so hence it will go to the other house to make sure (they use a medium condition with higher friction on the backends).
I'll keep an eye on it and throw it a little more over the next few weeks to make sure the result is what I want. If it ultimately does not, then I may potentially look to trade at my pro shop for an Infinite Theory. For some reason, it seems that since I started to use hybrids several months ago, they really match up with my game (throwing between 18-22mph, between 370-400 revs and play multiple lines.) Solids have always matched up well for me, so there is no sense in changing that. The bright side: since coming back to the sport several months ago, at least I am finding this out now before the fall league season starts.
My arsenal
Heavy Oil: Storm Virtual Gravity Nano: 2000 AB
Medium-Heavy Oil: Storm Anarchy: 1500 polished
Medium Oil: Roto Grip Nomad Dagger: 1500 polished
Medium-Light Oil: Roto Grip Rising Star: 1500 polished