If you've pulled the oil out then your likely fix is to take it down to about 500 and then skip to 2000. Spend more time at 500 and much less at 2000.
Today's high performance covers are "softer" than ever and they smooth out VERY FAST. As those microscopic peaks and valleys smooth out the ball will become less effective at displacing oil, and the "traction" that came from the factory is diminished.
This happens across the board regardless of manufacturer, but it's much, much, more than an oil absorption thing. For a cover to become oil soaked it can take anywhere between 40-60 games, while surface texture can be noticeable easily after a dozen games or so. I would refer you to the Innovative site to see their laser scanner results.
Oil absorption happens, but surface texture changes fast once the ball encounters friction, and EVERY ball needs to find friction in order to change direction.
I have awakened hundreds of Storm, Brunswick, and others over the years in the shop, so I'd recommend your not trashing the ball. It will likely respond when you find that ideal surface texture for your particular house. Hope this advice helps you. If you live anywhere near me, look me up as I can guarantee that I could help restore most, if not all, reaction. Best of luck to you, and Happy New Year full of strikes!
