Since it's an asymmetric, how you have it drilled can and usually does make a huge difference.
Have you tried any of the higher (finer) grits, like 1500, 2000 or 4000?
(2000 & 4000 usually need Abralon pads.)
Also when you polished did you use Magic Shine? It's a gritless polish, which means the underlying grit level doesn't change. When applying MS, you can apply a light version or a high gloss version.
Another option is to use Track's Clean and Sheen. It's a compound finish. That means the shine results are halfway between a matte or dull finish and glossy polish. One can start at any grit level, say 600 grit or 1500 grit and then apply C&S. It has abrasive (grit) in it and different amounts and different pressure can provide a wide ranges of finishes.
--------------------
"None are so blind as those who will not see."