My experience with magic shine is this, it seems to make the ball shinny as anything but, it is very tacky. It seems like the ball dosent glide through the heads like other polishes. Just seems tackier to me. With black magic, the ball slides through the front as good as anything but, bites hard in the dry.
I could personally care less how shinny or how good a ball looks after polishing (this is where Magic Shine is the best!!!!!). I care about performance that works for me so, I like Black Magic.
Edited on 7/30/2006 0:44 AM