Something to keep in mind is that 60,000 - 90,000 bowlers show up for this tournament. The shot has to be tough otherwise everyone would complain about how high the scores are. This is not your local city tournament with a THS. It is about quality shot making and a solid spare game.
Anyone who criticizes two teams playing together to open the shot is missing the point. Regardless of what the format is or how it changes, good bowlers will ALWAYS have strategies to deal with the conditions no matter what they are. Great bowlers will execute those strategies.
I do understand them oiling before S/D. Now everybody plays the same shot vs. luck of the draw with the left overs of the teams previous to you.
My one criticism for a team staying on one lane the whole event is that you lock the right-handed bowlers on the right lane on how far they can move left before stepping around the ball return (or opposite for lefties). Where the left lane would be open. That's usually not an issue for most, but still.
I love the tournament. I've never even shot 600 there playing off a 220 average. But that's on me. I know where my flaws are and I'm working on them to get better.
I agree with your first statement. Difficulty in the lane pattern also brings the cream to the top. You should have to work and be great at your craft to become a national champion. Some people would be happier not cashing shooting 620 than cashing shooting 550 because they could say they averaged 200+. I don't get it.
I don't think anyone is criticizing two teams working together to open the shot. But there are no 10-player team awards. Considering that if you don't have a companion team, you are at the mercy of "luck" on who you draw as a companion team, the same philosophy being implemented for fresh oil for singles and doubles, should be at least considered for the team event. Again, not every team that bowls goes with a companion team. Great teams will always have an advantage, nobody denies that. That's why they are great.
Good point about the ball returns, but I think the fresh oil will prevent anyone from needing to get that deep. Doesn't mean they won't try to get that deep, but do they really NEED to get that deep? We never got there this year and we were on the double burn (Team and singles & doubles squad before our S&D squad). But we did see a number of players way left, but I guess that's all in perspective in how you read the oil and where you think you NEED to be.
I love the tournament as well, tough condition and all and would bowl it whether it was fresh for all squads or not. Always a good time and bowling trip for me and my brother.
Good thoughts dogtown!