Not sure if you'd like the solid.
I like it at 2000 or 4000 matte with the pin above the ring finger, depending on how much oil there is.
When I polished it (over several different base grits), it did get flippier. I didn't like it - too hard to control. Polished, I think I'd want the pin at or under the level of the bridge and/or with the CG kicked out, depending on your ball speed (as per usual).
I think the Pumpkin is a wonderful ball.
I used the wrong drillings on my original Blurple. If I didn't have so many balls I'd get a new one and put the pin over the ring finger and leave it polished. (I had no idea just how strong that cover was).
--------------------
"None are so blind as those who will not see."